MYNIPPON: love and life guilt free.  Find out more about lifestyle, relationships, dating, health, fitness, cooking, beauty, fashion, and plastic surgery.

 

I love two men

How can I dump my loser boyfriend

Summary:  This is the story of Becky and in this second part I have reproduced an abridged version of my online chat with her in which I explained to her how she needs to dump her loser boyfriend and move on with her good boyfriend

Image of a lady who loves two guys at the same time

I recently left Steve, my fiancé of 10 years  (we dated for 8, were engaged for 2) for another man, Pete, because he refused to work full time, has a very negative attitude, wants a better life but doesn't want to work for it, and accused me of pushing him into the engagement. There are many more reasons, but those are some of the core issues. The man I left him for is the exact opposite.  He is kind, motivated, I melt when I look at him and he is the same for me. After hours of phone calls, I felt guilty and I missed my old fiancé, so I left the man I was with to come back and try and work things out. I am not attracted to him anymore, I don't want to have sex with him or anything related to that, we fight constantly, and yet, even though the other relationship was a happy, healthy relationship, I have this nagging feeling I need to see this through and stick it out. In short, I guess what I'm trying to say is that I love them both.  I want to get out of my old relationship, but I don't know if I should or I am just misbehaving, incredibly, even though the new man should have stuck up for himself and told me to get lost.  So far he still speaks to me and encourages me, whereas I feel torn apart with accusations (again, a reasonable way to feel on his part) by the old relationship. I want to leave and be with the other man, but something is holding me back, I'm unhappy, but there's a shred of hope that, maybe, I can fix the old relationship, even though things are really hard right now. I almost feel like being with the man who will treat me kindly and care for me is like running away to a party instead of doing my homework. I'm so confused and I'm stuck in limbo trying to figure out what the heck I'm doing.  Please help me.

There are a lot of things I do truly admire about Steve, like his mechanical skills, so long as he's not being paid to do it, he can fix a car with his eyes shut. His sister was murdered when he moved to Raleigh from New Jersey, he had gotten into a fight with her and she went for a walk and they never saw her again, so at first I understood why he was so controlling, he would want to know when I was leaving a place, what route I was taking, I would have to call him when I left and when I arrived at my destination. I allowed this and almost liked it, because it was safer, but when you give an inch, they take a mile. It got to the point where he was keeping me from my friends and family, not by saying "you can't see them" but by acting hurt and getting upset if I went anyways, crying foul because it took away from our time.

I know he loves me, when things are good; he'll bend over backwards to help me, in the small ways. I had a hard time because my mother is an alcoholic and I have spent most of my life trying to help her and pay her bills.  I became so heavily burdened in debt that I had to file for bankruptcy. This was last year. I had seen a million different credit counselors and what not, and he always refused to go, stating that it was none of his business and it made him uncomfortable. I told him if he wanted to marry me like he said he did, it WAS his business, that's when he came out with the whole "you pressured me into the engagement" thing.

My family is heavily military, my father was a Marine and he will never let us forget it so, when my brother stood firm on not wanting to enlist in any branch of the military, to keep the family line going I wanted to enlist in the Navy.  Steve didn't like that because he said while I was away in boot camp it would destroy our relationship, so he proposed to me instead. I accepted. For two years I waited for him to WANT to get moving, he would talk about buying a house, though he was working a total of 45 minutes to an hour a day, griped about not getting a raise, but never showed up for more than the stated time. My family had a great deal to say about this, and I fought them every step of the way, trying to defend him, but secretly, I knew they were right.

After a while I began to look at our relationship, saw it wasn't going to go anywhere and I just felt doomed.  I loved him blindly for so long, and then when that day came, I was no longer his cheering fan. I resented him. We had an online friend who played a game with us, and we had known each other for a little over a year.  I had never seen a picture of him, but he was just a great person and I really liked him, he made me feel like everything was going to be okay. It grew from there and he sent me a picture of himself (I had sent him a picture of Steve and I on a vacation so he already knew what I looked like).

Pete was the most beautiful man I had ever seen in my life. This tall, dark and handsome Japanese guy. I sent him another picture because I figured he didn't realize he was talking to someone who was most definitely not Asian, and I was scared he wouldn't want anything to do with me and we started talking about race and nationality. My mother is Native American, from the Choctaw tribe, and being a half-breed is not fun or easy.  I don't look Indian enough to fit in at all the functions and all of that, but I look just off enough that the other people see it or meet my mother and start spewing off stereotypes about Indians.  I can't win.

Pete is the same way. He's half Japanese and half white (well, he looks Japanese though), so he knew exactly what I meant when people would break out with "you know, your people" either trying to show what they knew or fit in, and all the aggravation in between. It felt so wonderful to have someone know exactly what I meant, and where I usually meet those issues with anger because of my own insecurities; he meets with patience and kindness. I was so scared I might offend him and sound like the other people that when we would wrestle and he'd try and get me to learn something from it (he has a lot of martial arts experience) I would just shut up and stay as far away from it as possible, anything that had anything to do with 'Asian things' at all, I wouldn't talk about. I didn't know anything, so the only thing that would be coming out of my mouth would be ignorance. He could tell something was wrong so he asked me about it and I told him how I felt; he was so nice about it!

He's always forgiving and kind and gentle, a part of me feels I don't deserve that, that he shouldn't be saddled with me, really.  Anyhow, when I came out to him, I was insanely happy, but then all this homesickness came back.  Steve kept calling my cell phone crying, one day he gave me the ultimatum that if I didn't come back by his birthday it was over and I got scared and I left to go back to Steve.

My reasoning was that I don't know if he would ever find another girl, he's overweight, anti social, and shy.  Pete, on the other hand, would be just fine without me; he didn't NEED me for anything. I know that's wrong but it did influence my decision.  Since I have been back, things have been awful; I can't sneeze without him analyzing it. I still can't believe Pete still talks to me, but he does. I have told him that this is not healthy for him and he needs to move on with his life and stick up for himself, but he still calls, which I am very grateful for. I think so highly of him, you just don't know, and I am so very sorry I even got this started. I never ever wanted to cause him pain, I want him to be as happy as he made me every day of his life, but because this is going on, he's miserable, and he begs me to come back to him, but I don't know if that's the right thing to do. I don't want Steve to hurt either. At the same time, I don't want to let go of either of them and I don't know what to do.

 
Related:  How to pick the right man out of two    Is my boyfriend a loser

Which man to choose    Does my boyfriend love me    Dating strategy

Secret relationship with married woman    Married man broke my heart

Will my girlfriend marry me     How to leave my married boyfriend

I am having second thoughts about my fiance    I am engaged but like another man

Marry extramarital lover    Women who tease men   My fiance is cheating

How to decide which man is better    I am married but have a crush on a friend

Second thoughts after proposal   I proposed too soon   I am torn between 2 men

Should I make love my married friend     Can a woman love more than one man

Why I ended my extramarital affair   How to choose between husband and lover

A Girl Cut In Two movie

Want to comment?

Copyright.  All rights reserved.   Privacy policy